Even if one regards the quantization and semiclassical issues as satisfactory, one has to face several hurdles in evaluating the theory. There are interpretational issues of the wave function obtained as a solution to the constraints, and also the problem of time or observables emerges . There is a wild mixture of conceptual and technical problems at different levels, not at least because the operators are quite complicated. For instance, as seen in the rewriting procedure above, the volume operator plays an important role even if one is not necessarily interested in the volume of regions. Since this operator is complicated, without an explicitly known spectrum, it translates to complicated matrix elements of the constraints and matter Hamiltonians. Loop quantum gravity should thus be considered as a framework rather than a uniquely defined theory, which however has important rigid aspects. This includes the basic representation of the holonomy-flux algebra and its general consequences.
All this should not come as a surprise since even classical gravity, at this level of generality, is complicated enough. Most solutions and results in general relativity are obtained with approximations or assumptions, one of the most widely used being symmetry reduction. In fact, this allows access to the most interesting gravitational phenomena such as cosmological expansion, black holes and gravitational waves. Similarly, symmetry reduction is expected to simplify many problems of full quantum gravity by resulting in simpler operators and by isolating conceptual problems such that not all of them need to be considered at once.
© Max Planck Society and the author(s)